Best Ice Cube Trays for 2026
Discover the best ice cube trays to elevate your beverage experience, from classic designs to innovative silicone molds that create perfectly shaped ice for cocktails, smoothies, and everyday drinks. Our expert reviews help you find durable, easy-release trays that fit your freezer space and match your entertaining needs.
Updated January 2026 • 18 Products Analyzed
The Good
- Effortless ice release with minimal twisting required
- Stackable design that prevents sticking and spillage
- Larger ice cubes and durable, sturdy construction
- Made in USA with BPA-free food-grade materials
Kitch Easy Release Ice Cube Tray (4-Pack)
The Kitch Easy Release Ice Cube Tray 4-pack delivers on its promise with effortless ice release through simple twisting and excellent stackability. Made in the USA with durable, BPA-free materials, these trays produce larger-sized cubes and earn consistent praise for reliability and durability. While occasional sticking issues arise with improper water levels, overall quality and performance justify the current price point.
The Bad
- Occasional sticking when filled to maximum capacity
- Easy release inconsistency in rare instances
The Good
- Easy ice release with flexible silicone bottoms
- Stackable design saves valuable freezer space
- Complete kit with bin, lids, and scoop
- BPA-free, durable, and dishwasher safe
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin - 4 Pack
This comprehensive ice cube tray system combines 4 silicone trays with lids, a storage bin, and scoop—perfect for space-conscious freezers. The flexible silicone bottoms make ice removal effortless, and the stackable design maximizes freezer organization while maintaining excellent quality. Highly recommended for everyday use and especially praised by elderly users and those with limited dexterity.
The Bad
- Scoop is very small, holds only 1-2 cubes
- Lids not airtight; allow freezer odor absorption
The Good
- Produces crystal clear ice spheres and cubes consistently
- Larger ice melts slower, reducing drink dilution
- Straightforward assembly and easy to clean
- Takes up less freezer space than DIY ice block methods
glacio Clear Ice Maker Set
The glacio Clear Ice Maker Set produces beautifully transparent ice spheres and cubes using directional freezing technology, perfect for whiskey and premium cocktails. While it requires 24-36 hours to freeze and some patience for removal, customers consistently praise the crystal-clear results and elegant presentation. The sophisticated design makes it an excellent choice for serious beverage enthusiasts.
The Bad
- Requires 24-36 hours freezing time per batch
- Removing mold requires patience and careful handling
The Good
- Large 2-inch cubes melt slower and fit perfectly in whiskey glasses
- Flexible food-grade silicone easy to pop cubes out
- Durable and sturdy, dishwasher safe with excellent longevity
- Great value for 2-pack with 16 cubes
Samuelworld Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds 2-Pack
These premium 2-inch silicone ice cube trays excel at creating large, slow-melting cubes perfect for whiskey and cocktails. Users consistently praise their durability, ease of use, and professional-grade results, though some mention odor retention and removal technique requirements. With great ratings across over 14,000 reviews, they represent excellent value for home bartenders and entertaining.
The Bad
- Can retain food and odor smells even after washing
- Removal technique takes practice; difficult if filled completely to top
The Good
- Easy pop-out mechanism with flexible silicone
- Secure lids prevent freezer odors and spills
- Compact size fits any cup or freezer
- BPA-free and dishwasher safe
Silicone Ice Cube Trays Set of 2 - Bamboo Green
These flexible silicone ice cube trays produce 15 smaller cubes per tray with included lids to prevent freezer odors. Reviewers praise the easy-release mechanism and stackable design, making them ideal for cocktails, baby food, and specialty freezing. However, some users report initial odor issues and difficulty with precise filling due to the flexible silicone material.
The Bad
- Initial odor requires soaking or baking to eliminate
- Flexible material makes precise water level difficult
The Good
- Produces perfectly clear, premium-quality ice cubes
- Melts slower, minimizes drink dilution
- Durable silicone construction lasts years
- Easy to use with tap water
True Cubes Clear Ice Cube Mold
The True Cubes clear ice cube maker produces bartender-quality 2" x 2" x 2" clear ice cubes that melt slowly, keeping cocktails from becoming diluted. Made from durable BPA-free silicone and award-winning by America's Test Kitchen, it requires simple tap water and an 18-22 hour freeze cycle. While the price is steep and freezer space can be challenging, users consistently praise its effectiveness and durability over years of use.
The Bad
- Takes significant freezer space while in use
- Premium price point
The Good
- Easy ice removal with flexible silicone construction
- Reinforced rim provides structural rigidity and easy filling
- Protective lid eliminates freezer odors and contamination
- Large, uniform cubes perfect for any beverage
W&P Peak Silicone Ice Tray
The W&P Peak Silicone Ice Tray combines premium food-grade silicone with reinforced steel rim construction for effortless ice removal and durability. Features a protective lid, produces large uniform cubes, and excels at releasing ice without the sticking problems common with standard trays. While pricey for an ice tray, the superior materials and thoughtful design justify investment for frequent users.
The Bad
- Higher price point compared to standard trays
- Lid lacks true seal and requires careful handling
The Good
- Flexible rubber construction enables easy ice extraction
- Rigid base tray prevents spills and provides stability
- Includes protective cover to block freezer odors
- Perfect cube size with excellent durability and reliability
Lekue Industrial Ice Cube Tray
The Lekue Industrial Ice Cube Tray is a flexible rubber tray with a rigid base that makes ice extraction effortless and prevents spills during freezer transfer. Users consistently praise its ease of use, durable construction, and reliable performance compared to alternatives. The included cover helps prevent freezer odor absorption, though hand washing is recommended to maintain longevity.
The Bad
- Requires hand washing; dishwasher use causes deformation
- Covers may not always be included with order
The Good
- Perfect fit for slim water bottle openings
- Food-grade silicone is durable and flexible
- Easy ice cube removal with independent compartments
- Versatile for multiple uses beyond water
Webake Silicone Ice Cube Trays (Pack of 3)
The Webake Silicone Ice Cube Trays excel at creating long, narrow ice cubes perfectly designed for water bottles with slim openings. Made from food-grade silicone with excellent temperature tolerance, these trays offer versatility for various applications from beverages to creative projects like resin casting. While highly functional and easy to release, some users note handling difficulties when full of water before freezing.
The Bad
- Difficult to handle when full before freezing
- Soft silicone lacks rigidity during transport
The Good
- Sliding lid design prevents freezer odors and spills effectively
- Innovative rounded cubes release easily with minimal effort
- Sturdy construction stacks efficiently and saves freezer space
- Dishwasher safe and BPA-free for easy maintenance
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray - 2 Pack
The OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray delivers thoughtful design with its innovative sliding lid and easily removable rounded ice cubes. Users consistently praise its intuitive functionality and space-saving stacking capabilities, though some note concerns about freezer door compatibility and fill-line clarity.
The Bad
- Width may not fit standard freezer door shelves
- No clear water fill line causing overflow and sticking
The Good
- Slow-melting spheres keep drinks perfectly chilled
- Complete kit with storage bin and tongs included
- Durable, rigid plastic design with dishwasher safe
- Twist-release mechanism makes removal effortless
Whiskey Ice Ball Maker 2-Pack with Storage Bin
This complete ice-making set delivers large, slow-melting spheres ideal for whiskey and cocktails, combining ease of use with a convenient storage solution. Users consistently praise the effective twist-release mechanism, durable plastic construction, and thoughtful kit design. However, the ice balls are smaller than advertised, and achieving perfectly clear spheres requires distilled water, limiting convenience for everyday use.
The Bad
- Ice balls are smaller than restaurant-quality spheres
- Requires distilled water for crystal-clear results
The Good
- Crystal clear, large cubes stay frozen longer than plastic
- Exceptional durability withstands freezing cycles without cracking
- Individual cube removal prevents damage and corner chipping
- BPA-free silicone with premium food-grade construction
Tovolo Silicone Ice Cube Tray Charcoal Gray Pack of 2
The Tovolo Silicone Ice Cube Tray produces perfectly shaped 1.25-inch cubes that remain crystal clear and last significantly longer than traditional plastic trays. Made from premium BPA-free silicone with exceptional durability—some users report 11+ years of reliable use—these trays are dishwasher safe and offer easy individual cube removal. While cube extraction requires a slight twist-and-push technique rather than tumbling out freely, the superior build quality and restaurant-grade appearance make this a worthwhile investment for serious cocktail enthusiasts and daily ice makers.
The Bad
- Requires twist-and-push technique to extract each cube individually
- New trays may have manufacturing residue requiring vinegar rinse
The Good
- Select and release individual ice cubes easily
- Stackable lid prevents freezer odors and spills
- 14-cube capacity with secure, quality construction
- Twist-and-push mechanism is intuitive and user-friendly
Joseph Joseph Duo QuickSnap Ice-Cube Tray
The Joseph Joseph Duo QuickSnap offers convenient individual ice cube release with a secure stackable lid that prevents freezer odors and spills. Users praise its easy-to-use mechanism and impressive design, though some report difficulty with the initial release process. Overall, it's a well-regarded premium ice tray with innovative features and strong customer satisfaction.
The Bad
- Initial ice cube removal can be difficult without wait time
- May require patience for cubes to fully release from mold
The Good
- Creates elegant, slow-melting spherical ice
- Food-grade silicone, dishwasher safe, easy removal
- Excellent value for budget-conscious buyers
- 100% lifetime guarantee and leak-proof design
Housewares Solutions Froz Ice Ball Maker
The Housewares Solutions Froz Ice Ball Maker creates elegant, slow-melting spherical ice perfect for beverages and cocktails. Made from food-grade silicone with a lifetime guarantee, it's dishwasher safe and delivers excellent value. While filling requires a learning curve and ice balls are modest in size, users consistently praise its quality and ease of use.
The Bad
- Requires careful filling technique to avoid stems
- Ice balls are smaller than some prefer
The Good
- Creates perfectly round, slow-melting ice spheres
- Food-safe, BPA-free durable silicone construction
- Flexible, non-stick design for easy release
- Dishwasher safe for convenient cleaning
Host Silicone 2" Ice Sphere Mold
This silicone ice sphere mold creates two large 2" ice balls perfect for whiskey and cocktails. The slow-melting design prevents drink dilution while maintaining flavor integrity. Made from BPA-free, food-safe silicone with dishwasher-safe convenience for easy cleanup.
The Bad
- Limited to two spheres per mold set
- No existing customer reviews to verify performance
The Good
- Perfectly round ice spheres release easily with gentle twist
- Compact stackable design ideal for small freezers
- Includes convenient storage bin and fitted lids
- Ice stays colder longer, melts slower than standard cubes
WIBIMEN Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
WIBIMEN offers an attractive round ice sphere tray set with convenient storage bin and lid, featuring easy ice release and compact design. Users consistently praise the perfectly formed ice balls, ease of use, and aesthetic appeal, though some report concerns about plastic durability and overall build quality.
The Bad
- Plastic feels cheap; brittle and prone to cracking
- Bin lid doesn't snap shut completely; water spillage when snapping together
The Good
- Easy ice cube ejection with button mechanism
- Compact design perfect for small freezers
- Includes storage bin and comes with two trays
- Food-grade materials safe for storage
Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 2 Pack
This innovative ice cube tray features an easy-release button mechanism and comes with a storage bin, making it compact for small freezers. While users praise its convenient ejection system and cute mini cube size, the product has notable quality control issues and requires careful handling to function properly.
The Bad
- Inconsistent quality and assembly issues between units
- Fragile construction requires precise use or breaks easily
The Good
- Significantly slows ice melting for longer drink enjoyment
- Simple two-piece design is easy to use
- Creates impressive large ice spheres for cocktails
Cocktail Kingdom 2 Inch Ice Ball Mold
The Cocktail Kingdom Ice Ball Mold creates large, slow-melting ice spheres perfect for premium spirits. While users praise its ease of use and ice longevity, quality control issues and durability concerns have plagued some batches, resulting in warping and breakage problems.
The Bad
- Quality control issues including warped molds and sizing discrepancies
- Durability concerns with molds breaking during regular use